One topic that stuck out
at me was in the beginning of chapter four on labeling students. Labels stick
to people and then people often “become that label” according to those people
judging them. For instance, someone with a physical disability becomes a
cripple.
“Describing a complex
person with one or two words implies that the condition labeled is the most
important aspect of the person. Actually, the individual has many
characteristics and abilities, and to focus on the disability is to
misrepresent the individual. An alternative is ‘person-first’ language or
speaking of ‘students with a behavior disorder’ or ‘students placed at risk.’
Here the emphasis is on the students first. For example, we would say ‘students
receiving special education’ NOT ‘special education students’” (Woolfolk, 2013,
p.117).
I had four feet/ankle
surgeries in three and a half years just because of bad genetics. I spent a lot
of time in a walking boot and on crutches. When we would go places I couldn’t
believe the amount of stares I would get, because I was “different.” To be
honest, kids are the worst about staring and I understand it is completely
because of curiosity and that is not “normal” to them. However, as a teacher it
is important to constantly remind students that everyone is different. We don’t
all have the same abilities. Just because someone is in a wheelchair doesn’t
mean they can’t do what you and me do; they just will do it in different ways.
Another point on this
topic is people who have a mental illness. I know many people affected by
mental illness. My cousin was just diagnosed with depression and bipolar. My
little sister said to me, “Kimmie, I know I shouldn’t be, but I’m afraid to be
around Bobby after finding all this out.” I told her she has no reason to be.
Bobby hasn’t done anything to her or anyone else to make us feel afraid. I said
the best thing all of us could do is treat Bobby the way we always do. We need
to say, “Hey Bob! What’s up?” like things are still the same. I said if you
treat Bobby any differently, he’s going to feel even more embarrassed than he
probably already does from his recent behavior. Bobby is still the same old
Bobby. Just because he has bipolar doesn’t mean he is bipolar; he’s still
Bobby.
I enjoyed reading about your insights on labeling. I also had experience with surgery on my ankle last year. I went through the process of crutches and being carried everywhere for about a month until the doctors figured out how to get me walking again. During that time, it did not bother me that people were staring at me hopping and falling all over the place because I knew it was temporary. You are right that we need to teach students that everyone is different and it is important to treat everyone with kindness.
ReplyDeleteGoing along with what you said about putting labels on people. I also think some children do not believe in themselves and if someone were to put a label on them such as 'average' they may believe it. If they believe the labels people give them, they may never know their full potential.
Kim,
ReplyDeleteIt is really an interesting thing to think about, when we reflect on the public reactions people that to those that are different. I don't want to call it human nature, because I refuse to give up and allow something that I consider to be an ignorant behavior to be one of things that define us. Babies and young children are an obvious exception, as it is our responsibility as parents to teach them as they grow. One of the things we must teach is how to be polite and courteous to people in public. It doesn't matter if they are friends, family, or strangers. Everybody deserves respect, and staring or gawking at people in public just because they are different is not a sign of respect. I love your insight in that a teachers we have responsibility to remind children that this is okay. Often, our teachings will contradict negative things that parents pass on to children. We must be mindful of this, but at the same time hold true to what we know is right. Even if somebody has a disability and can't perform the same things we do, it doesn't make them less of a person. We are of all walks, sizes, colors, shapes, and abilities.
There was a time that I judged remorsefully and often. I would allow ego to take over my mindset, and if somebody in public had a disability or was different in some way, my mind would subtly pass judgement. No matter the origin of this thinking, I realized that it had to be changed. I am still far from perfect, but I have been able to move most of these thoughts to the conscious level and am able to realize that they are not to be gawked at any more than any other person.
I have a brother in law who has the same condition as your cousin. It is difficult to engage in conversation with him because I lack the strength to handle it sometimes. He has threatened suicide in the past, and I find it hard to remain a viable consul to him. It is something I am constantly mindful of, but I wish I had more strength to be able to help him.
Kim,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your blog this week. I am in total agreement with you on labels sticking. It's great timing because this week I was helping create a training class for one of my jobs and one of the most important bullet points was people first language. Yesterday at my other job, one of our new managers use the word handicapped and I'll be honest with you, it bugged me. I feel like it's Hospitality 101 to use people first language.
Labeling people and judging people based on labels is disrespectful, sadly, it will never go away. Just because one has to travel in a wheelchair, doesn't make him any less human or deserving of the respect that we all would want. We should not let a disability define who they are. Look at the Olympian Amy Purdy, bronze medal winner for snow boarding and now a top performer on Dancing with the Stars. She lost both her legs when she was 19, but did not let that stop her. On Yahoo.com Amy stated "Only True Disability Is in Our Minds." She is a true inspiration and role model for those who have been labeled have decided to let that label define them. Those with disabilities need encouragement that they can do whatever they set their minds too, it may might hard work, but they shouldn't let that stop them.
Kim,
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with you, I also found the beginning of chapter 4, where it was talking about labeling, quite interesting. I will be honest; I have to remind myself, especially after reading this, to put the student first when talking about someone who requires different needs. I was definitely guilty of doing this in the past, but now after reading it in our text, I feel as though I will be much more aware of how to address it.
You are completely correct when you talk about teachers having to be really aware of this labeling issue. When students hear their own teacher describing it wrong, they too also do it, making the situation a never-ending issue. You know this firsthand as you described how children perceived you when you had your foot in the boot after your surgeries.
In my house, we are also dealing with the labeling issue a little bit because my youngest daughter, Samantha, has severe food allergies. Next year she begins kindergarten, and a lot of the studies we have read show how the levels of bullying among classmates are extremely high. Many of these are linked back to the teacher because of the way they put the spotlight on the child with the allergies. For instance if a child brings a snack in for birthday, the teacher might say, “Samantha can’t have that because she's allergic to it” and now, all of a sudden, everyone is looking at Samantha as though she is different. This goes back to talking about how important it is for a teacher to remind the students that everyone is different and just because they can't do or have something that everybody else can, they still deserve to be treated equal.
Kim,
ReplyDeleteI think this was a smart topic to choose to blog about. Labels do stick. More than often people do not realize they are creating labels or see no harm in it. You are so right. Labels do coin those aspects of the person as most important. Fortunately, in high school everyone knew me as, "the cheerleader who does all of the flips"! Even though this is a positive label there is much more to myself than cheerleading and flipping. The person-first strategy seems like a good way to help prevent some labels. I will be honest. I try my best not to, but I am more than often bad about staring! Sometimes I feel like it is because things are different or out of the norm. This does not mean different is bad or unacceptable, you are just not use to it. No matter how polite you try to be it is tough not to take a glance. I know from my own experience.